Articles
/ Article
Articles

Designing Circular Business Models: From Ideation to Implementation

In the current environment, we see that more and more companies are looking for ways to innovate their business models in order to create sustainable alternatives to current solutions. Implementing a circular ecosystem that solves an environmental problem while offering an attractive value proposition to customers is the ultimate goal.

Insights
January 27, 2021
10 min read
TAGS
Business Modeling
Venture Building
Sustainability
AUTHOR

Richard Stechow

Managing Consultant

As discussed in the previous article, the Circular Navigator is a helpful tool for this. In the following article, we take a deeper look at the steps that are needed to get from generating new and sustainable ideas to implementing these.

Patterns for developing a Circular Ecosystem

Based on the review of more than 200 successful sustainable businesses in cooperation with the Unversity of St. Gallen, a classificatory framework has been developed. This framework categorises four types of patterns crucial to creating a circular ecosystem. Together, these four pillars allow to shape a financially valuable and attractive offering while simultaneously achieving sustainable resource loops.

Four types of patterns to create a circular ecosystem

  1. Close the loop: What makes the solution circular? Reusing products, but also creating products that can savely enter the biosphere again.
  2. Improve the loop: Circularity alone does not mean that the solution is sustainable (think rebound effects). With this category, sustainable patterns are presented that improve the loop. These can range from increasing the longevity of the product, making it more efficient, increasing its functionality (to make others productsunnecessary) or decreasing the number of products being used.
  3. Monetise the loop: There are many ways to monetise circular solutions. The goal is always to find an attractive solution for the customer that simultaneously ensures the recovery of the produts. The question then becomes how the partners in the ecosystem will work together, how value can be created for all of them and how the revenue model can be designed across the whole value chain.
  4. Excite the loop: Last but not least, always keep the customers in mind. Excite them by creating solutions that are engaging and offer an attractive value proposition - think about options such as additional services, transparency, or platforms.

The Circular Ecosystem Patterns can be divided into four categories.

The company should fundamentally ideate new value propositions and value creation mechanisms along a circular ecosystem. Two methods of ideation can be distinguished – the structured and unstructured method. For the structured ideation, you start with generating ideas from patterns of the first pillar and consequently move through the others. This method is more manageable for the participants but creates a path dependency as certain patterns from the last pattern are not applicable to the ideas you created from the earlier categories.

Using the unstructured method, all solutions are basically the result of a freestyle brainstorming. This is beneficial due to the flexibility and adjustability, however, it is significantly more demanding for the participants.

Integrate: Designing a Circular Ecosystem with the Circular Canvas

Once you’ve come up with a variety of ideas, the next step is to design a holistic ecosystem from them. For this purpose, the Circular Canvas helps to simplify the complexity of the circular economy, creating a high level overview of the circular value chain by merging the material flow and the business perspective.

The interior parts of the circle are composed of three phases: make, use and recover. The exterior circle has the take and dispose phase. These follow the logic of the circular economy, forcing you to come up with solutions that close the loop.

The purpose of the canvas is to sort, select, create and design the ecosystem. The best ideas are selected and integrated to the canvas - ask yourself: do these ideas work well together, are other ideas better suited, are some gaps left? You always create your ecosystem around a product & shared value of proposition (think about it: there are no circular services - only services that facilitate the circular flow of materials).

In the corners of the canvas, four strategic factors are shown. These factors are very important for shaping the ecosystem.

The Circular Canvas consists of four strategic factors

  1. Product design – In order to recover products, they need to be designed properly. Here is the place to gather the respective ideas.
  2. Metrics - The status quo has to be determined as well as the the possibility to track the progress.
  3. Financing– There is a time lag from the creation of the circular product to the recovery. It is not easy to hold together the ecosystem for years until it is functioning and a lot of thought needs to be put into how to achieve this.
  4. Packaging & Logistics – Between all value creation steps, the products need to be transported. Think about ways to ensure that these steps are as sustainable and efficient as possible.

The Circular Canvas facilitates the design of a circular ecosystem.

Afterwards, we propose to take a deeper look into the activities that you want to handle and the ones that are important and need to be realized by a partner. Create a sustainable business model and use tools such as the reverse financials to ensure that your concept can be realized profitably.

Creating a common circular vision

The fifth step Imagine is a key element of circular transformation. A common vision is formulated which addresses the purpose of the ecosystem and shared value proposition. This is fundamental for the alignment within the company, potential partners, customers and employees. The goal is to motivate and to create a shared understanding of why the activities are done. Without a convincing vision why the company should change, success depends mostly on luck and circumstances. The most common challenges in the circular economy transformation process is the lack of awareness regarding the need for sustainable innovation and a hesitant company culture.

For example, Tesla‘s vision is to accelerate the world’s transition to sustainable energy. Patagonia aims to build the best product, cause no unnecessary harm, and use business to inspire and implement solutions to the environmental crisis. Wear2Wear has circular solutions in which many companies are involved in, their vision is to manufacture high-quality textile products from 100 percent recycled textiles. Interface’s mission is to overcome the biggest challenge facing humanity: reverse global warming. There is no formula to create the company vision, but it is very important to have the meaning and company goal described as precise as possible.

A common vision is formulated which addresses the purpose of the change.

Incorporating circular ecosystems

Once solutions have been created and designed, the next step is to incorporate the partners. It is essential that the invovled companies are able to adjust their business models  and create shared value propositions with a measurable impact. Getting partners on board is the first step. Before finding and approaching partners it can be helpful to have a plan and an ideal vision for the ecosystem on board. The better the understanding of the envisioned ecosystem is, the better suitable partners can be identified. Sometimes, partners are onboarded earlier in the process, but if you have no common starting point, it works best to offer your own vision and solution as a basis for cooperation. This takes a lot of time, therefore it is important to make sure to identify the most important partners and the ones that are interchangeable. Align on the ecosystem and value proposition and iterate the first steps together when needed.

After onboarding the neccessary partners, each company needs to implement the solution within their boundaries and coordinate the changes within the company and across the ecosystem. Motivation, communication and coordination are key for success.

These implementations often need to be accompanied by a cultural change for the involved companies, since they are on very different levels of implementing circularity and sustainability into their organisational structure. Depending on that, various barriers and challenges are to be faced.

‘I strongly believe in the cooperation of companies. I call it the integrated textile line.’
– Tommy Verminck, Decontex

Timing is very crucial, as in some of these ecosystems, the recycling partners will only start being involved on an operative level after 3 to 4 years. It is important to continue motivating the partners to stay on board, which is why a common vision and story is so important. An orchestrator within one or two companies, who feel obligated to realize the solution really need to drive it forward. Sometimes, partner companies stop collaborating or have internal struggles. This is the reason why a driving motivator who feels responsible is fundamental.  

Oftentimes this also involves cooperating with competitors to make solutions financially viable. Circular ecosystems cannot work with one company alone and thanks to the collaboration with competitors, attractive solutions can be put into place.

No items found.

Implementation and time for action

Last but not least, the planned circular solutions need to be realised. For each company, implementing the ecosystem takes place at the individual business model level. As is already known from the business model innovation perspective, it is crucial to move in small steps to test quickly. Basically, implementation is about making each business model work by testing the most important assumptions and aspects of it as quickly as possible to make sure the end-customer receives the solution they want. The most common issue here is to lose sight of the customers as the internal perspective (within the company and the ecosystem) is so complex that it demands a lot of attention. However, creating solutions that are not aligned with customer needs is a surefire way for failure.

Richard Stechow

Managing Consultant

Conclusion

Circular-Navigator-Cover-with-shadow.png

As mentioned before, a lot of time is needed to design and then adjust the business model in alignment with envisioned solution and ecosystem. A systematic approach helps to better handle the complexity - have a large plan, but realize the solution step-by-step. For the Circular Economy, it is neccessary to make sure that everyone involved understands the goal and vision - and why these need to be pursued.

Do not let yourself be overwhelmed by the high complexity, solutions can be designed systematically - the most important part is to start acting now to actively shape these solutions and position your company for (circular) success!

Interested in additional information on circular business models? Take a look at The Circular Navigator and download the corresponding whitepaper on Business Model Innovation for the Circular Economy.

RELATED INSIGHTS

We share what shapes our work and creates pivotal seconds. Mostly through our scientific and entrepreneurial perspective.

Cases

How Voestalpine set up a new Business Incubator in two Months

Voestalpine wanted a repeatable way to turn steel know-how into new revenue. In a two-month project we trained the incubator team in Business Model Innovation tools and applied them to two live ideas. The process is now the standard path for every major innovation project inside the steel division.

Training
Business Modeling
Structure & Processes
Sustainability
Chemicals 
& Materials
Cases

How ZF Brandenburg Plotted Life After Combustion Gearboxes

ZF’s Brandenburg plant makes manual and dual-clutch gearboxes, about 120 000 units a year. As demand shifts to electric drives the work will dry up. In twelve months we ran the Business Transformation Navigator with staff and external experts. Together we shaped three new business models and built full investment cases, giving the site a clear future path and protecting jobs.

Business Modeling
Consulting
Venture Building
Mobility
Mobility & Transport
Cases

How Schaidt Turned Insolvency Into an E-mobility Comeback

When its last audio-electronics contracts vanished, Schaidt Innovations filed for insolvency. Instead of closing the plant, we ran a fast business-model innovation sprint that created a new plan to build electric-vehicle charging stations. The strategy convinced Webasto to acquire the site and keep 170 jobs.

Business Modeling
Consulting
Venture Building
Mobility
Mobility & Transport
Cases

How a Refractory Leader Tripled its Recycling Rate

A global supplier of refractory products wanted to scale battery recycling and make circularity pay. In one year we used the Circular Economy Navigator to pick the right business model, test it with customers and build a roadmap. The work led to a joint venture that tripled the company’s recycling rate and cut waste costs.

Business Modeling
Consulting
Venture Building
Sustainability
Manufacturing
Cases

How Roche Builds Innovation Capabilities Across its Global Workforce

Roche wanted its people to spot and shape new business opportunities. We designed a four-part learning journey that teaches business-model thinking, design and testing. The program has already trained hundreds of employees and helped internal teams push new venture ideas forward.

Business Modeling
Training
Chemicals 
& Materials
Manufacturing
Health
Cases

How a Nuclear Technology Leader Entered EV Battery Recycling

A French industrial group known for nuclear fuel cycles wanted to use its metallurgy skills in electric-vehicle battery recycling. Over three years we mapped the market, designed business models and set clear decision points. The work led to joint ventures for battery components in northern France and a pilot recycling plant that is now under construction.

Business Modeling
Consulting
Sustainability
Energy
Articles

Managing the Path Forward: Six Insights on Developing Business Models for the Circular Economy

Don’t be afraid of twists in the path to a circular future. Many companies are here, too. Here's how to manage and predict this transition.

Business Modeling
Sustainability
Articles

How is AI Transforming Operations and Business Models?

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become a game-changer across industries, transforming how businesses operate. Let's delve into the numerous ways AI is reshaping business models and operations, helping organisations stay ahead in today's fast-paced digital world.

Business Modeling
Digitalisation
Articles

Navigating Sustainability in Business

A conversation with Richard Stechow and Vera Hermes for Haufe Academy

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Sustainability
Articles

The Characteristics of Data-driven Business Model Development and how to Succeed

The experience of recent years shows that companies often overestimate the value of their own data and their own ability to generate revenue from it. In practice, very few companies can establish a sustainable business model based on data.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Digitalisation
Approaches-Frameworks

Business Model Innovation Basics Series - Part 3: How to Create Successful Business Models

Understanding the steps for business model creation

Business Modeling
Approaches-Frameworks

Business Model Innovation Basics Series - Part 2: Why Business Model Innovation Matters

Learnings from sports competitions

Business Modeling
Approaches-Frameworks

Business Model Innovation Basics Series - Part 1: What is a Business Model?

Introducing the Magic Triangle of Business Models

Business Modeling
Approaches-Frameworks

Changing Customer Needs Call for new Business Models in Urban Mobility

Urban Mobility is an industry with a long history, but it is also one of the most dynamic industries in recent years. Many new businesses have emerged, some with rather innovative business concepts and others without.

Business Modeling
Mobility
Mobility & Transport
Approaches-Frameworks

The new Platform Navigator: How to Design and Implement Platform Business Models

What do eight out of ten of the most valuable companies worldwide have in common? They are built upon a platform business model.

Business Modeling
Articles

Key Trends in 2022 That can Influence Your Business Model

Nowadays it is increasingly complex to keep pace with new market trends, because changes happen very quickly. But we know that it's really important to recognize these industry changes early on in order to be able to keep up with technology for the benefit of long-term business planning, to stay ahead of the curve and prevent rivals from overtaking you.

Business Modeling
Sustainability
Articles

Our 7 Favorite Newsletters

Newsletters have been around for many many years. Probably even for hundreds of years. We wanted to share our current most popular selection of newsletters with you.

Business Modeling
Strategy
Culture
Structure & Processes
Venture Building
Articles

Does AI Replace Human Work?

The world is becoming more and more interconnected and narrow due to technology and is closely connected like a village. Reaching around 126 billion U.S. dollars by 2025 the global artificial intelligence (AI) software market is forecast to grow rapidly in the coming years (Liu, 2020).

Business Modeling
Strategy
Digitalisation
Culture
Structure & Processes
Articles

Our 7 Podcast Recommendations about Innovation and Entrepreneurial Spirit

Did you know? The number of podcasts went through the roof in the past two years! In fact, as of April 2021, PodcastInsights recalls that there are over 48 million episodes available from over 2 million shows worldwide! We think this is just the beginning.

Business Modeling
Strategy
Digitalisation
Culture
Structure & Processes
Articles

Combining Scenario Management and Business Model Thinking: Why Strategic Agility is the new Way to Define your Corporate Strategy

Strategy implementation often turn into strategy justification - the necessary questioning of changes in the environment or the exploration and testing of alternative options is not perceived as invigorating but as disturbing.

Business Modeling
Strategy
Structure & Processes
Culture
Articles

How to Create Business Models for 5G - and Other Disruptive Technologies

“Build only products that customers want” – sounds easy, right? However, in practice, this can be quite hard. Sometimes, companies approach us with requests like “I have developed a new technology but how do I build a business around it?” or “Our technology is superior to our competitors’ – why don’t our customers see that?”.

Business Modeling
Digitalisation
Other Trends
Articles

How to Fight Climate Change With Innovative Business Models

This should not come as a surprise: Climate change is one of the biggest challenges that humankind faces today with a wide range of negative impacts such as droughts, floods, rising sea levels, ocean acidification, and loss of biodiversity. Due to its complexity, there is no easy, quick-fix solution to address it.

Business Modeling
Other Trends
Sustainability
Articles

How to Explore the Full Potential of Digital Transformation Through Innovative Business Models

Digitization is not new – many digital technologies have been around for more than a decade now and have profoundly changed the way we live. Yet, few established businesses seem to have a clear vision of how to best navigate the change brought about by digitization.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Other Trends
Digitalisation
Strategy
Articles

How to Develop Innovative Ideas Together – Online

What do you miss most about working from the office? While many workers are happy to do without long commutes and fixed working hours, there is one thing many of them miss: stimulating exchanges with colleagues, jointly identifying problems and spinning wild ideas.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Other Trends
Digitalisation
Strategy
Articles

The Rise of Second-hand: Exploring the Opportunities of Re-commerce

The fashion resale market is booming. By 2029, it is forecasted to reach a value of $80 billion, doubling the size of fast fashion. As used clothing is taking over our wardrobes, we have decided to explore the phenomenon of resale from a business model perspective – and investigate how it can be applied to other industries.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Sustainability
Consumer Goods
Other Trends
Articles

Designing Circular Business Models: From Ideation to Implementation

In the current environment, we see that more and more companies are looking for ways to innovate their business models in order to create sustainable alternatives to current solutions. Implementing a circular ecosystem that solves an environmental problem while offering an attractive value proposition to customers is the ultimate goal.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Sustainability
Articles

The 5 Business Model Patterns You Should Follow in 2021

The world is digital – that is, at least since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic. There are many current examples of digitization that are interesting and prove the importance of a robust business model.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Health
Articles

Implementing New Circular Business Models with the Circular Navigator Methodology

The focus of many companies is currently on sustainability, however a big gap still exists between the actions taken and the current state of the planet.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Sustainability
Tools

150+ Tools to Easily and Quickly Test Your Business Model

“Which tool do we need to test this business model?” This is the most frequently asked question since we started implementing innovative business model ideas with our clients. The answer? There is no perfect tool for your test. There are a lot out there and the key is to select the one that best suits your needs.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Articles

COVID-19: The Digital Transformation Catalyst of Banking Business Models

The banking industry faces change, probably in a never known pace and relevance than before. Although COVID-19 had a positive impact on some banks due to a high increase in asset trading volumes and associated commissions, it also acts as a transformation catalyst. COVID-19 is assumed to substantially change the consumer behavior towards a cashless society. The trend towards a hybrid banking customer is continuing.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Health
Articles

Introduction to the Circular Economy

The environmental issues humanity is experiencing on the planet nowadays are unprecedented and require new innovative solutions from businesses, which have mostly been operating in a linear manner.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Articles

4 Inspiring Ideas to Overcome Challenges when Testing Innovative Business Models

Following our recent article about the most common challenges faced by companies when testing innovative business models, we decided to highlight 4 inspiring initiatives that seem to be effective practices to overcome these challenges.

Business Modeling
Venture Building
Articles

What we Have Learned About Testing Business Models

A superior business model is the base of sustainable business success. Studies show that 90% of business ideas change several times before achieving commercial success and over two new products/solutions out of three fail to meet customer expectations.

Strategy
Business Modeling
Venture Building
Articles

7 Steps to Prepare Your Business Model for Post-COVID-19

Uncertainty and risk will remain high. How can we deal with these difficulties? COVID-19 has influenced many industries and companies. Together with our customers, we discussed an approach to tackle this uncertainty.

Strategy
Business Modeling
Health
Approaches-Frameworks

The 5 steps for Implementing Digital Business Models

The increasing popularity of creativity methods such as Design Thinking and the St. Gallen Business Model Navigator have led to a state where companies are now well equipped to generate many innovative ideas. The better the first step of business model innovation is mastered, the clearer it becomes that the true challenges for companies lie in the following phases: translating ideas into validated business model concepts and turn them into profitable businesses.

Strategy
Business Modeling
Digitalisation
Cases

Business Model Innovation from the CES 2020

The CES Las Vegas is the first global show of the year for companies thriving on the business of consumer technologies. As passionate innovators, we looked at the innovations presented at this year’s show and analyzed them from our business model innovation point of view.

Strategy
Business Modeling
Cases

Business Models – Definition and Reason

When you read about anticipated changes due to IoT, Industrial IoT, or Industry 4.0, you inevitably come across the term business model. Usually, it is the conclusion based on the changes anticipated by the IoT: You have to innovate or change your business model. But more often than not, that’s all you get and you’re left to figure out how to do that on your own.

Strategy
Business Modeling
Cases

How Omya Built a Focused AI Strategy in Industrial Minerals

Omya wanted a clear plan for using artificial intelligence across its operations. In a four-phase project we assessed readiness, set goals, selected pilot uses and built a scale-up roadmap. The result is a ranked list of AI priorities and a governance model that keeps efforts aligned.

Consulting
Digitalisation
Chemicals 
& Materials
Strategy
Cases

How PostAuto Reinvented its Business Model for the 21st Century

With a fleet of 2,400 vehicles, a network spanning more than 12,000 kilometers, and 155 million passengers transported every year, PostAuto is the market leader in public bus transport in Switzerland. For more than 100 years, the subsidiary of the Swiss Post has provided regional and rural bus services throughout the entire country.

Business Modeling
Consulting
Digitalisation
Mobility
Cases

How a Traditional Industrial Manufacturer Unlocked the Value of Software-based Solutions

Founded in the first half of the 19th century, Europe’s largest industrial manufacturer looks back on a long and eventful history. With the passing of decades, the company has grown into a truly global player with 350k+ employees and 200+ production facilities around the world.

Business Modeling
Consulting
Digitalisation
Cases

How an Ag-tech Leader set up Value-based Pricing with Farmers

A global ag-tech company wanted to sell its high-performance seeds straight to farmers. We led a one-year BMI Launchpad project, co-developed a value-based pricing model and tested it in three countries. The pilot showed that farmers gained better yields and the company captured more value when both sides shared risk and reward.

Agriculture & Food
Digitalisation
Business Modeling
Consulting
Venture Building
LET’S TALK

Science, entrepreneurship or consulting? Every innovation journey starts with a conversation. Pick 
the perspective that resonates - and let’s begin.

Prof. Dr. Christoph Wecht

Managing Partner

Georg von der Ropp

Managing Partner

Timo Nührich

Managing Director